The Impact of Voucher Programs on Public Schools in Texas: Why Defunding Public Schools is a Bad Idea

Michelle Beckley

Uncover the impact voucher programs have had on public schools in Texas and how defunding these institutions would be detrimental to student success.

Public schools are the backbone of the American education system, providing education, skills, and knowledge to millions of children across the country every day. In Texas, however, these schools are under threat from an increasingly popular debate about whether to defund them with voucher programs. This move could have a significant impact on the quality of education and student performance in public schools across the state.


In the last legislative session, none of Denton County's State Reps voted to fully fund public schools, which raises the question of why this issue is gaining traction and what the potential consequences are. If you're a pro-public-school Democrat, you're likely wondering what voucher programs are and how they could affect the schools that you support. In this blog, we'll take a closer look at voucher programs and their impact on public education in Texas.


1. What are Voucher Programs and How Do They Affect Public Schools?

Voucher programs, also known as school choice or education savings accounts, provide funding for families to send their children to private schools instead of public schools. The funds may also be used to pay for homeschooling, tutoring, or online education. While these programs may sound appealing in theory, they can have a negative impact on public schools.


Voucher programs siphon funding away from public schools, which rely on these funds to pay for teachers, educational resources, and facilities. When these funds are taken away, it can lead to larger class sizes, a decrease in teacher salary, and ultimately, a lower quality of education for students who attend public schools.


2. The Impact of Voucher Programs on Student Performance

Proponents of voucher programs argue that they improve student performance by giving families more educational options. However, research shows that voucher programs do not lead to a significant improvement in student performance. In fact, studies show that states with voucher programs have lower academic achievement than those without them.


Furthermore, voucher programs can lead to a more divided education system. Schools that accept vouchers may not be required to follow the same educational standards as public schools, which could lead to an uneven playing field for students from different backgrounds.


3. The Cost of Voucher Programs to Taxpayers

While voucher programs may sound appealing to parents who want more options for their children's education, they come at a cost to taxpayers. Voucher programs send public money to private schools, which may not be held accountable for how they use the funds. This can lead to misappropriation of funds, loss of transparency, and a lack of oversight.


Moreover, voucher programs may not be accessible to all families. It may be difficult for low-income families to afford the remainder of tuition costs, which means that these programs may benefit only those who can already afford to pay for private education.


4. The Importance of Fully Funding Public Schools

Given the potential negative impacts of voucher programs, it's crucial to fully fund public schools. Public schools play a vital role in American society, providing education and opportunity to millions of children every day. It's essential that these schools receive the resources they need to fulfill their mission of educating our youth and preparing them for the future.


Moreover, fully funding public schools means that all children have access to high-quality education, regardless of their socioeconomic background. It's the responsibility of elected officials to ensure that public schools are fully funded and that all children have equal access to educational opportunities.


In conclusion, voucher programs represent a significant threat to the quality of public education in Texas. They can lead to a reduction in funding for public schools, a lack of accountability for private schools, and a more divided education system. Instead, fully funding public schools is the best way to ensure that all children have access to high-quality education and that the next generation is adequately prepared for the future. As citizens, let's advocate for fully funding public schools and promoting educational equity for all.


By State Representative Michelle Beckley 06 Jul, 2021
The city council of Carrollton, Texas provided comments regarding House Bill 4072 , which was proposed during the 87th Texas Legislative Session. The city council of Carrollton, Texas expressed their opposition for HB 4072 . HB 4072 sought to simplify and clarify local sales and use tax administration by establishing as the state’s default sourcing method a destination-based method under which sales are sourced to the location where the item is shipped or delivered or where the purchaser takes possession. HB 4072 requires that local sales taxes be collected and reported based on an item’s final destination as opposed to the transaction location. The city council of Carrollton voiced that the proposed changes would have disproportionally impacted cities with large commercial bases, placed undue burden on businesses, and caused unintended consequences. Our office also reviewed the potential impact of HB 4072 on the City of Lewisville. If HB 4072 had been passed, the changes would have resulted in an annual loss of more than $10 million in sales tax for Lewisville. Lewisville would have likely faced reduced services and employee layoffs across all city departments, including police and fire departments. The Office of State Representative Beckley proudly represented the interests of Carrollton and Lewisville, by opposing this piece of legislation. HB 4072 intended to address a perceived inequity that results from the misuse of Chapter 380 agreements, but the Comptroller already has the authority to invalidate these types of agreements. Cities use Chapter 380 agreements to grow their economies and benefit their communities. HB 4072 was unsuccessful during the 87th Legislative Regular Session; it was voted out of the Ways & Means House Committee but did not make its way to the House Floor. HB 4072 was left pending in the Calendars Committee; the Calendars Committee has jurisdiction over the placement of bills and resolutions on appropriate calendars. The 87th Regular Session ended on May 31, 2021. Sincerely, State Representative Michelle Beckley
By State Representative Michelle Beckley 22 Jun, 2021
Are you or a loved one heading to college this Fall? Does he/she/they need financial help? The Office of Representative Michelle Beckley is asking for submissions for the Texas Armed Services Scholarship. The Texas Armed Services Scholarship (TASSP) has been created to assist promising students from the State of Texas who are committed to education and service. It encourages young leaders to participate in the Texas Army National Guard, the Texas Air National Guard, the Texas State Guard, the United States Coast Guard, the United States Merchant Marine, or to become commissioned officers in any branch of the armed services of the United States. Each year the governor and the lieutenant governor may each appoint two students, and each state senator and each state representative may appoint one student to receive an initial conditional scholarship award. The amount of the award will be up to $10,000 and cannot exceed the student’s cost of attendance. Eligibility for Nomination: Students selected must meet two of these four academic criteria: Be on track to graduate or have graduated high school with the Distinguished Achievement Program (DAP), the distinguished level of achievement under the Foundation High School program, or the International Baccalaureate (IB) Program Have a high school grade point average (GPA) of 3.0 or higher on a 4.0 scale Achieved a college readiness score on the SAT (1020) or ACT (23) Be ranked in the top one-third of the prospective high school graduating class Eligibility for Award: To receive a scholarship, an appointed student must: Be registered with Selective Service or be exempt Be enrolled an in good standing in a Reserve Officers’ Training Corps (ROTC) program or another undergraduate officer commissioning program as certified by the institution Maintain satisfactory academic progress (SAP) as indicated by the financial aid office at the recipient’s institution of higher education Enter into a written agreement with the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board (THECB) Complete school-initiated Texas Armed Services Scholarship Program application by October 15, 2021 Repay the scholarship if requirements are not met If you’re interested in the Texas Armed Services Scholarship Program, please send your resume and a short essay (300-500 words) explaining your interest in the program to Michelle.Beckley@house.texas.gov . You will receive an update to your nomination status by July 9, 2021. Feel free to reach out to our District Director , Ariana Johnson, if you have any questions about the Texas Armed Services Scholarship Program. Thanks and good luck! Please note: The scholarship applicant should be a House District 65 constituent. If you are unsure of who represents you in Texas, find out here . Best wishes, State Representative Michelle Beckley
By Representative Michelle Beckley 22 Jun, 2021
The Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) issued a statement on Monday about tight grid conditions due to the high number of forced generation outages. Provided below are resources for customers to report electric outages, check meter usage, view outage maps, and find contact information for energy providers. Remember - a failure to plan is a plan to fail. Be sure to visit these resources before it's too late. Oncor Resources CoServ Resources Texas-New Mexico Power Resources The Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUC) Resources ERCOT's request to conserve energy during peak hours (3-7 p.m.) continues through Friday. Be sure to follow these energy tips to help reduce electric use. Set thermostats to 78 degrees or higher Turn off lights and pool pumps Avoid using large appliances Turn off and unplug items that are not in use or are unnecessary
Show More
Share by: